I Don’t Trust My Realtor — What Do I Do?
Choosing a realtor is one of the most important decisions in the home-buying or selling process. You’re trusting someone to guide you through complex negotiations, legal paperwork, and massive financial decisions. But what happens when you don’t trust your realtor? Maybe you feel they’re not being transparent. Maybe they rush you, avoid questions, or push deals that don’t feel right.
If your instincts are signaling that something is off, you’re not alone—and you don’t have to stay stuck. Here’s what to do if you find yourself questioning your realtor and how to protect your financial interests moving forward.
🚩 First: Identify Why You Don’t Trust Them
Before taking action, clarify the source of the distrust. Common concerns include:
• Lack of communication — slow replies, no updates, or vague answers.
• Pressure tactics — pushing offers/contracts, saying “This is your only chance.”
• Conflicts of interest — steering you toward in-house lenders, inspectors, or buyers.
• Incomplete disclosures — avoiding or downplaying inspection issues or market data.
• Misaligned priorities — they seem focused on commission, not your goals.
• Dishonesty or inconsistencies — numbers change, or statements don’t match reality.
Write down specific examples. This helps you decide if the relationship can be repaired or if it’s time to move on.
🧰 Step 1: Have a Direct, Professional Conversation
Many issues come from misunderstanding or communication styles. Try a direct conversation before cutting ties:
What to say:
“I need more clarity on the timeline and next steps. Can we set consistent update times?”
“I don’t feel confident in this recommendation. Please explain the pros and cons of other options as well.”
“I want to make sure our priorities align. My top goals are ____. Can you support that?”
The goal isn’t confrontation—it’s clarity. A trustworthy realtor will respond professionally and make improvements. If they get defensive, dismissive, or irritated, that’s a bigger red flag.
📑 Step 2: Review Your Contract
Most realtor relationships involve an Exclusive Buyer’s or Seller’s Agreement, legally binding you for a specific period. If you need to end the partnership, you must understand your contractual obligations.
Key terms to look for:
Contract length and expiration date
Termination clause
Fees or penalties for cancellation
What happens if you sell or buy without them
Their duties and your rights
If you aren’t sure how to interpret something, ask another brokerage or attorney for help—many offer free or low-cost contract reviews.
🕵️♂️ Step 3: Get a Second Opinion
You don’t need to break ties to get clarity.
Ask another realtor, broker, or real estate attorney:
Would they price the house similarly?
Would they recommend different negotiation strategies?
Do they interpret your current realtor’s advice as standard, questionable, or unethical?
Are there better financing, staging, repair, or marketing options?
A professional second opinion helps you confidently confirm whether your realtor is acting properly—or not.
Bonus: You can ask another agent for a comparative market analysis (CMA) to check whether the pricing advice seems honest.
🚪 Step 4: Know You Can Request an Agent Change
If your realtor belongs to a brokerage (like Keller Williams, RE/MAX, Century 21, etc.), you can escalate concerns to the managing broker.
Say this:
“I’m not comfortable continuing with my current agent. I’d like to be reassigned within the brokerage.”
Brokerages want to keep your business. They may resolve the issue or replace your agent.
❌ Step 5: If Necessary, Terminate the Contract
If trust is broken beyond repair:
How to end the relationship ethically:
Check your termination clause.
Send a written notice.
Request a mutual release form.
Confirm whether any fees apply.
Keep documentation for your records.
If you feel trapped by the contract or they refuse to release you, ask an attorney about your options. Sometimes improper conduct is grounds for termination.
⚠️ When You Should Consider Reporting Them
If you believe your realtor is being unethical, deceptive, or potentially breaking laws, you can file complaints with:
Their brokerage
State real estate licensing board
National Association of Realtors (NAR)
Better Business Bureau (BBB) (for pattern documentation)
Reasons to report:
Hidden offers or dual agency conflicts
Refusing to present offers
Misrepresentation of market data
Fraud or falsified paperwork
Pressuring you to skip inspections
Even if you don’t report immediately, keep copies of emails, listing agreements, messages, and contract changes.
🧠 Trust Your Instincts — It’s Your Money, Not Theirs
Remember:
Your realtor works for you.
They do not control your decision.
And they cannot force you into any contract or sale.
If something doesn’t feel right, pause.
🔐 How to Protect Yourself Moving Forward
Here’s how to stay in control:
1. Never sign anything on the spot
Take every document home. Review it. Ask questions.
2. Keep everything in writing
Verbal promises are worthless without proof.
3. Research every recommended service
Appraisers, lenders, inspectors—don’t rely on one referral.
4. Educate yourself
Learn market conditions, comparable sales, and fair buyer/seller strategies. A good agent supports your knowledge; a bad agent fears it.
💡 When Choosing a New Realtor, Look For:
✔ Transparency and patience
✔ No pressure sales tactics
✔ Experience in your local market
✔ Genuine listening skills
✔ A communication plan (how often updates happen)
✔ A realistic—not inflated—value estimate
✔ Positive reviews that feel authentic
✔ Clear boundaries and documented expectations
Interview at least three agents before committing.
Ask every candidate:
“How do you prefer to communicate and how often?”
“Can we set performance benchmarks?”
“What happens if I’m unhappy with the process?”
“Do you have references I can speak to?”
Final Thoughts
You are not powerless in this situation.
Real estate is a major financial milestone, and you deserve someone who respects your goals, time, and trust. Whether the relationship can be repaired or you need to move on, you absolutely have options.
Trust is earned—not assumed.
If your realtor isn’t earning it, you’re allowed to walk away.
Explore Our Current Listings to Find Your Perfect Home with Sonic Realty
Or, if you're looking to direct visitors to more resources:
Learn More About Our Real Estate Services and How We Can Help You Buy or Sell Your Home
Let me know if you need links for specific sections or pages on the website!
Thank you for reading! If you enjoyed this article and want to explore more content on similar topics, check out our other blogs at Sonic Loans, Sonic Realty, and Sonic Title. We have a wealth of information designed to help you navigate the world of real estate and finance. Happy reading!