Title Insurance Claim: A Comprehensive Guide on How to File and Navigate the Process

Title insurance is a crucial safeguard for real estate transactions, protecting property buyers and lenders against potential title defects. While title issues are uncommon in most property transfers, they occasionally arise, leading to disputes over ownership, undisclosed liens, or other legal complications. If you’ve purchased title insurance and a defect in the title later surfaces, knowing how to file a title insurance claim can save you from significant financial and legal troubles.

This article provides a detailed overview of the steps in filing a title insurance claim, the types of title issues that can arise, how title insurance works, and what to expect during the claims process.

Understanding Title Insurance

Title insurance is different from other forms of insurance because it protects against past issues rather than future events. When you buy a property, a title search is performed to uncover any potential legal matters related to the property, such as unpaid taxes, undisclosed liens, boundary disputes, or clerical errors in past deeds. However, some title defects may not be uncovered during this search. Title insurance protects the buyer (and lender) if these hidden defects come to light later.

Suppose an issue does arise after you’ve purchased the property. In that case, title insurance will cover the legal fees associated with resolving the dispute and any financial loss you suffer as a result.

Common Title Defects That Lead to Claims

Title issues can vary widely, but some of the most common problems that lead to title insurance claims include:

Errors in Public Records: Clerical or filing errors can cause inaccuracies in the title, such as incorrect legal descriptions or improperly recorded deeds.
Unknown Liens: Previous owners may have taken out loans against the property that needed to be settled appropriately, leaving the new owner with an unexpected financial obligation.
Fraud or Forgery: Past fraudulent activities, such as forged signatures on documents, can raise questions about the legitimacy of the title.
Missing Heirs: In some cases, undisclosed heirs or beneficiaries may emerge with a claim to the property.
Boundary Disputes: Conflicting property surveys can lead to disputes with neighbors over where the property lines are drawn.
Undisclosed Easements: Easements allow another party to use part of your property for a specific purpose, such as utilities. Undisclosed easements may affect your rights to the property.
Unresolved Legal Judgments: Previous owners may have legal judgments against them that result in liens or claims on the property, even after you’ve purchased it.

Step-by-Step Guide to Filing a Title Insurance Claim

Suppose you discover a problem with your property’s title. In that case, acting quickly and following the appropriate steps to file a claim with your title insurance company is essential. Below is a detailed guide on how to navigate the claims process.

Review Your Title Insurance Policy

The first step in filing a title insurance claim is carefully reviewing your policy. The title insurance policy you purchased when closing outlines the specific coverage and the types of title defects it protects against. Be sure to check the following aspects:

Coverage limits specify the maximum amount the insurer will pay to cover your losses.
Covered risks: These are the specific issues your policy covers, such as fraud, liens, or undisclosed heirs.
Exclusions: Some policies may exclude certain types of claims, such as disputes arising from easements or zoning issues.

Reviewing your policy will help you better understand whether your insurance covers the issue you’re experiencing and what potential remedies are available.

Gather Documentation and Evidence

Next, gather all the necessary documents related to your title issue. This will help you substantiate your claim and give the title insurance company a clear picture. Key documents may include:

The title insurance policy itself.
Deeds and other paperwork from the original purchase.
Any correspondence regarding the title defect, such as letters from lawyers, lenders, or potential claimants.
Survey reports if boundary disputes or easements are at issue.
Document financial losses incurred due to the title defect, such as costs related to unpaid liens or legal fees.

Providing thorough documentation upfront can expedite the claims process and help resolve the issue more efficiently.

Notify Your Title Insurance Company

Once you have gathered all the relevant documents, the next step is to notify your title insurance provider. Many title insurance companies have specific procedures for filing a claim, so following their instructions is essential. Typically, this involves sending a written notice to the insurance company detailing the issue with the title and requesting coverage under your policy.

In your notice, include the following information:

Your policy number.
A description of the title defect or issue you’ve encountered.
Copies of supporting documents (such as deeds, notices, and financial records).
Contact information for relevant parties (such as the attorney or lender involved in the dispute).

Some title insurance companies may have an online portal for submitting claims. In contrast, others require you to send your notice via mail or email.

Wait for the Title Insurance Company’s Response

After you’ve submitted your claim, the title insurance company will investigate to determine the validity of your claim. This process can take some time, as the insurer must review your policy, the title history, and any documentation you’ve provided.

During the investigation, the title insurance company will typically do the following:

Review the title defect and verify whether it falls under your policy’s coverage.
Check the title search and closing documents to determine if the issue could have been discovered earlier.
Consult with attorneys or other experts to assess the potential legal ramifications of the title defect.

Depending on the issue’s complexity, the investigation could take several weeks or months.

Resolution of the Claim

Once the title insurance company has completed its investigation, it will issue a response regarding your claim. If your claim is deemed valid, the insurer will typically offer one of the following solutions:

Defend Against Claims: The title insurance company may provide legal defense if a third party challenges your property ownership. This includes covering court costs and attorney fees.
Pay Financial Losses: If the title defect results in financial losses (e.g., you owe money for an undisclosed lien), the insurer may cover these costs up to your policy’s coverage limit.
Correct the Title Defect: In some cases, the insurer may work to correct the title issue by negotiating with lienholders or other claimants to resolve the dispute.
Settlement Offer: If the title defect cannot be quickly resolved, the insurer may offer a financial settlement. This payment compensates you for your losses or covers the cost of a diminished property value.
Appeal if Necessary

If your claim is denied or if you are dissatisfied with the resolution offered by the title insurance company, you have the option to appeal the decision. Start by requesting a detailed explanation for the denial. If you still believe your claim is valid, you can escalate the issue by:

Requesting a review by a higher authority within the insurance company.
Mediating the dispute through a third-party mediator or legal professional.
Filing a lawsuit if all other avenues fail and you believe the insurer has unjustly denied your claim.

If you encounter difficulties during the claims process, it’s often helpful to consult with an attorney specializing in real estate law.

Conclusion

Filing a title insurance claim can be a complex process. Still, it’s an essential step to protect yourself from potential losses if a title defect arises after you’ve purchased a property. You can navigate the claims process more efficiently by understanding your policy, gathering the necessary documentation, and following the proper procedures.

Remember that title insurance is there to shield you from financial loss and legal challenges related to the title. Whether your claim is resolved through legal defense, monetary compensation, or corrective action, having title insurance can offer peace of mind and protect your investment in your property.

“Explore Our Current Listings to Find Your Perfect Home with Sonic Realty“

“Learn More About Our Real Estate Services and How We Can Help You Buy or Sell Your Home”

Let me know if you need links for specific sections or pages on the website!

Thank you for reading! If you enjoyed this article and want to explore more content on similar topics, check out our other blogs at Sonic Loans, Sonic Realty, and Sonic Title. We have a wealth of information designed to help you navigate the world of real estate and finance. Happy reading!

Provider and Settlement Service	Charge or Range of Charges
Sonic Realty LLC	1%-6% of purchase price
Sonic Title Agency, LLC	Title Insurance Policy: $950 - $1706 on a $250,000 property. (Rates vary and are dependent on the state, selling price, and loan amount on the property.) Title Search Fee: $250 - $325 (where applicable) Closing Fee: $450 - $650
Sonic Loans Inc. This company provides various real estate mortgage loan origination activities either as a third-party originator or a mortgage broker, including loan pre-qualification, competitive bid process (when providing third-party origination services), loan origination, loan pre-approval, loan structuring, processing, and closing.	Loan Origination Charge: 0-3 % of loan amount (may include 3^rd party fees) Loan Discount Fee/points: 0.5%-6% of loan amount. Application/Processing Fee: $0.00 - $875.00 Flood and tax service: $0.00 - $95.00 Underwriting Fee: $0.00 - $1295.00 Document Review Fee: $0.00 - $400.00 Appraisal Fee: $0.00 - $850.00 Credit Report Fee: $0.00 - $135.00 Actual charges may vary according to the particular lender selected, the particular services provided, and the underlying transaction, borrower selections, etc. Some or all of these fees may be charged by third parties and/or the Member Mortgage Lender/Mortgage Broker. The Member Lenders and Mortgage Brokers have agreed to pay a fee ranging from 0.5% to 2.75% of the loan amount to Sonic Loans in connection with a range of loan origination services provided by Sonic Loans to the Member Lender/Mortgage Broker. The fees are paid either directly to Sonic Loans by the Member Lender/Mortgage Broker or billed directly to you at closing.

Provider and Settlement Service	Charge or Range of Charges
Appraisal Fee	$0-$800
Credit Report Fee	$63-$125